Anakin Skywalker's Redemption

[captmorgan72]

Found this on youtube and thought it was fantastic. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fiJ7Xf5EUZE&feature=related

[oldmanwinters]

I like the concept, but that sure is a LOT of Vader head shaking from the 2:50 onward!  It could have benefited from some flashback clips to accompany the audio.

[captmorgan72]

I agree with the head shaking. He shouldn't have looped that. Other than that, I thought it packed an emotional punch.

[cmdrkoenig67]

I don't know....In my opinion, it's kind of terrible.  To me, it smacks of Lucasism (adding and editing where it's not necessary).  The original scene had more than enough emotional impact without all the drivel of the prequel voice-overs thrown into it.  The looping is just awful, as well.

Dana

[catwhowalksbyhimself]

I agree.  I was not impressed.  It was just the original scene with a boring loop and a few sounds put in their.  I know what he was trying to do, but it really adds nothing to the original sequence as it originally stood.  The struggle and decision were obvious enough already and is more powerful that way it was originally done, IMO.

[deano_ue]

seems like usual unneeded sloppy crap lucas adds in, so maybe it is profeshional